The following excerpt is the revised section 2.10 of my On Human Temporality: Recasting Whoness Da Capo.
The mind’s shifting its focus to an essencing situation in one of the three temporal dimensions, within a nimbus of threefold presencing ‘all at once’ from all three temporal dimensions in the course of some practice or other, lets it come to mental presence. Here, for convenience, the discussion is restricted to a single-minded focusing of the mind’s attention on just one of the three temporal dimensions without, however, restricting the validity of the observations to be made.
For any factual situation in one of the three temporal dimensions to ‘be’ at all, it must i) essence in the shared psychic temporal openness which, in turn, ii) enables its being understood as such-and-such by an individual mind (or some individual minds) presencing the situation in its focus. It essences, first of all, by potentially presencing for and absencing from mind in the all-encompassing openness of three-dimensional time. Actual mental presencing for the understanding mind enables any situation to be understood in some way or other, including being misunderstood. Such interpretive misunderstanding is attributable first of all, in an elementary case, to the situation itself partially concealing itself or rather, conversely, deconcealing itself only partially or distortedly to the mind. The situation itself may also deconceal itself as what it is not, i.e. deceptively. There may be no difficulty in recalling a situation from memory i.e. in represencing it from mental absence, but the recalled situation must also be understood, i.e. interpreted, one way or another, and this understanding itself may be deficient, distorted, incomplete, entirely deceptive which amounts to partial concealing or deceptive deconcealing. Although represenced, the situation is only deficiently deconcealed; mental presencing and deconcealing thus do not coincide. Note that here we are considering only factual situations, and not the underlying hermeneutic cast of mind in a given age, such as our own, which is generally taken for granted and remains invisible.
In traditional discussions, that are generally fixated upon factual sensuous presencing, preference is given to sensuously present situations toward which the mind can intentionally direct its bodily sense organs, especially its visual ones, that is, the eyes. The sensuously present situation is potentially present for the mind — if only it would turn its sense-perceptual attention toward it. In so doing, the situation is sensuously presenced from absence and thus, through this presencing, is revealed, or deconcealed (entborgen), to the mind more or less fully and clearly through the senses, that is, as long as the senses themselves are not deceived.
It must be underscored that both concealment and deconcealment presuppose presencing for the mind or absencing from it. In other words, presencing and absencing in the all-encompassing openness of three-dimensional time are more originary phenomena than concealing and deconcealing, both of which depend upon and are essential features of more originary mental presencing and absencing. As we have seen above (cf. 2.5 Temporally threefold mental presencing), temporally three-dimensional presencing ‘all at once’ comes into its own especially when considering action, practice, making and physical movement, or any other kind of movement, i.e. existential movement necessarily involving presencing and absencing. Hence the movement of concealing and deconcealing for the individual mind is itself embedded, as it must be, in the more originary movement of mental presencing and absencing in three-dimensional temporality itself. In particular, absencing is the phenomenon of essencing (temporally and temporarily) out of the mind’s (temporally fourth-dimensional) presencing purely and simply. The mind is distracted, has turned its attention away or has lost its attentiveness. That is to say, all that mentally absences (essents, situations) is temporally absent in three-dimensional time from the fourth temporal dimension and, insofar as it can potentially (δυνάμει) presence, is only temporarily absent, and from this absence it may presence in the psyche’s interpretive mind and be deconcealed more or less undistortedly, with such distortions and defects amounting to concealment of the factual situation in itself. Otherwise, for a given individual, it may even be unable to presence clearly in the mind at all.
The bodily senses have a perceptual power (δύναμις) to sense and perceive a physically local situation presented to them (whilst not of themselves making sense of, i.e. understanding it as such-and-such). (The locally presented situation may rely on more or less sophisticated technological means of communication from remote places to ‘localize’ it.) Thus the bodily senses are activated (ἐνέργεια) in an act of perception, whereby the sensuously present situation is indeed deconcealed, but only to the extent that it reveals itself undistortedly and undeceptively to the senses. Insofar, sensuous presencing and deconcealing go together, but mixed with partial concealing or false deconcealing. Hence, for example,(fn23) a figure standing in a field can present itself to the sensuously observing eyes and mind from afar as (interpretable — incorrectly — as) a human individual, whereas closer up it turns out to be (interpretable — correctly — as) a scarecrow. The initial sensuous perception turns out to be false (i.e. a false factual interpretation) and is corrected by a view closer up, in better light, that reveals more to the sense of sight. The perceptual error in this case can reasonably be attributed to a lack of sensory power of the bodily sense organ, the eye, its perceptual capacity. From afar, certain details of a situation simply cannot be sensuously perceived by eyesight in the given illumination, thus leading to the false factual interpretation. In another situation, however, it may be the situation itself that does not fully deconceal itself, as in the case where the buildings in an urban environment wholly obscure the view of the mountain behind, as if the mountain were not there at all, or where a cupboard is positioned on a wall, thus entirely concealing the unused door behind, as if the door were not there at all.(fn24) The door is physically, locally present to the observer, but concealed from the observer’s mind that is deceived by appearances. (For the person who moved the cupboard to hide the door, it is not concealed at all, but recallable to mind from memory.) In such cases, it is a deficiency of the sensuously perceptible situation itself that prevents a factually correct sense perception due to the situation itself only partially deconcealing itself to the senses or presenting itself falsely as something else. Local presence and mental concealment here go together. Note that deconcealment is so far being discussed only in the sense of correctness, i.e. in the factual situation’s being correctly, rather than falsely, deconcealed as such-and-such. Its truth is a different, deeper matter that will be discussed later (cf. 6 Temporalogical recasting in historical time).
Deconcealing is not solely a feature of sense perception in the present, but pertains to presencing from all three temporal dimensions, and that not only of physical situations. In calling to mind an as yet absent future situation such as the signing of a contract of purchase, an experienced solicitor may have in view all the necessary conditions and the proper formulation of clauses without omitting any detail that would leave a legal loophole open for the other party. The mentally presenced, as yet absent future situation of signing is thus fully deconcealed with regard to all the necessary legal precautions, but not with regard to other details that may well remain concealed because they have no bearing on the contractual transaction (such as where the signing is to take place). The deconcealment of the as yet absent future contractual situation to the solicitor’s presencing mind is independent of whether the envisaged purchase ever actually (ἐνεργείᾳ) comes about, i.e. whether the expectation of an executed purchase is disappointed and never presences in the present. The solicitor’s past experience has already revealed (or deconcealed) to him all the pertinent details that can be carried over to the envisaged futurally absent signing of the purchase contract, whereas a young and inexperienced solicitor may omit certain important clauses safeguarding the prospective purchaser’s interests. In such a case, the absent future envisaged situation is present to mind but only imperfectly deconcealed, again independently of whether the envisaged purchase ever comes about, i.e. presences in the present. The deconcealment, imperfect or otherwise, has to be distinguished from a correct, foresighted prediction, e.g. that, given the circumstances, the signing will actually take place. Deconcealment here must therefore not be confused with any notion of ‘predictively seeing into the future’.
Agreements such as contracts and treaties represent the attempt to deconceal and bring possible absent future movements, i.e. contingencies, under control through a binding agreement among parties giving their word, thus constituting a kind of bond. Their word is a pro-mise (Latin promissum) that is ‘sent on ahead’ to bindingly control the foreseen contingencies of possible future situations that are as yet absent and may never presence in the present (as in insurance contracts), but presence for the foreseeing mind. The contract or treaty, however, must deconceal and properly articulate in language future eventualities. The various contingencies, firstly, must be mentally deconcealed in order to be taken account of in the binding word of a contract or treaty and, secondly, the parties to the agreement must accept the obligation to be bound by their promised word by giving their word. The mind’s envisaging a future situation amounts to its imagining through the fourth temporal dimension events, situations, eventualities, etc. in the temporal dimension of the future.
With regard to the deconcealment of a now absent past situation that presupposes its presencing for the mind, this is usually called remembering or recalling from memory. The mind shifts its present focus by turning its attention to that now irretrievably absent past situation presently out of mind, and entering into that temporal dimension to ‘be’, i.e. to presence mentally, the situation itself, and not some representation or replication of it somewhere ‘inside’ the mind or even the cerebrum. You may recall (mentally presence), for instance, having spent a few days in a hotel in a certain city one summer and remember (deconceal) many of the details such as its location in the city, its surroundings, the look of the room and the breakfast room, the friendliness of the staff, etc. but altogether fail to recall the hotel’s name. By remembering, you are presencing the hotel in that past situation through the fourth temporal dimension from the now absent past and are there with the hotel itself in that city that past summer, but the recalling-presencing leaves a detail, i.e. the hotel’s name, concealed, forgotten. This example illustrates that such attentive presencing-with may reveal many of the details of a past situation, including the gist of its most important features, but it may also fail to deconceal important features or even mistakenly recall details that never occurred or occurred (essenced) on some quite different occasion. Such mistaken recalling, or imaginative inventiveness, may be motivated by present concerns to make an absent past situation congruent with a different present one (such as telling a good yarn in company) that likewise has to deconceal itself when the mind presences it, perhaps in a deficient or distorted way that amounts to the mind’s misunderstanding it or leaving decisive details concealed.
Deficiencies in deconcealment thus abound in every factual (i.e. ontic) situation that presences for the mind from the temporal present or the other two temporal dimensions. Conversely, there are essencing situations presencing from all three temporal dimensions that are potentially factually deconcealed, but the distracted mind fails to presence them by turning its attention, or having its attention drawn, toward them; they remain thus absent from the mind. In that case, the individual’s existential movement has something else in mind from three-dimensional temporality. Situations in any of the three temporal dimensions of past, present or future, may be either present to or absent from mind. In this sense, paradoxially, the present may be absent or the past or future present. It is therefore risky to speak of the past or the future as temporal dimensions of absence, at least with regard to presencing (Vergegenwärtigung) for the mind. It must be underscored that speaking of an as yet absent, not yet present future situation or a now absent, no longer present situation invokes an entirely different sense of presence and absence than that pertinent to presencing for and absencing from the psychic mind in the fourth temporal dimension. In other words, the temporal dimensions of past and future are dimensions of temporal absence only with respect to the temporal dimension of the present, and not with respect to the fourth temporal dimension of the psyche endowed with its interpretive mind.
Further reading: On Human Temporality: Recasting Whoness Da Capo (OHT) De Gruyter, Berlin 2024.
(fn23) Cf. Plato’s similar example in Philebos.
(fn24) Cf. Heidegger Parmenides GA54:47.
